The list price of £425,000 seems reasonably priced given that comparable semi-detached properties in the area show higher prices (e.g. £445,000 on Malton Avenue). The condition, while not perfect, is above average and the presence of a garden adds value. However, the absence of precise square footage data for the property and neighboring properties makes a precise price-per-square-foot comparison difficult, preventing a higher score.

The property appears to be in generally good condition based on the photos. While some areas show signs of older styling, the kitchen and bathroom look recently updated. Other rooms appear well-maintained but could benefit from some modernisation to fully align with current market trends. This results in a moderate score.

The property is located in Heworth, York, which benefits from being within 20 minutes’ walking distance of York city centre. The proximity to good schools such as Heworth Church of England Primary Academy (rated ‘Good’ by Ofsted) also adds to its desirability. While specific amenities are not detailed, the area is likely to have shops and transport links given its proximity to the city center. However, the lack of precise information on these factors prevents a higher score.

The property features a garden, which is a positive aspect. However, the provided plot size is 0.00 sqft, which is contradictory to the image showing a garden. Assuming the images are accurate, the garden size appears modest rather than exceptionally large. Hence, a moderate score is given.