The list price of £299,950 seems somewhat high considering the provided comparable properties in the area and the lack of specific plot size details. While some nearby properties have sold for more, there is also evidence of similar properties sold for considerably less. The average price per square foot is unavailable from the supplied data, hampering a definitive assessment.

Based on the provided photos, the property appears to be in generally good condition. The interior is clean and well-maintained, with modern fixtures and fittings in the kitchen and bathrooms. While the property looks well-maintained, there is nothing to suggest that it is exceptional or luxuriously finished, hence the score.

The property is located in Maes Waldo, Fishguard, which benefits from proximity to schools, shops, and transport links. The presence of nearby train stations (Fishguard and Goodwick) and several primary schools within walking distance enhances its desirability. However, the lack of detailed information on local amenities and the overall vibrancy of the area prevents a higher score.

The property includes a garden, but its size is not specified and appears relatively small based on the photos. While having outdoor space is positive, its limited size is reflected in the lower score.