The list price of £725,000 seems reasonable considering comparable properties on Dudley Road. However, the absence of precise square footage data for nearby properties and the significant variation in prices of comparable properties (some being much higher) requires a more conservative score. The lack of plot size also makes precise comparision difficult. The property’s condition requiring some investment is also a factor affecting the score.

Based on the provided photos, the property appears to be habitable but requires some modernisation. While the structure looks sound, the interior finishes (kitchen, bathroom) seem dated and would benefit from refurbishment. The garden also appears somewhat unkempt, suggesting potential maintenance needs. Therefore, a middling score is assigned reflecting the need for upgrades.

The property is situated on Dudley Road in Walton-on-Thames, a desirable area in Surrey. Proximity to Walton town centre with its amenities (shops, restaurants, cafes) contributes positively to the score. The presence of several schools within a reasonable distance further enhances its appeal. However, the lack of detailed information on the immediate neighborhood and its specific characteristics prevents a higher score.

The property has a garden, which is a positive aspect. However, the provided images suggest a relatively modest garden size. There’s no quantifiable data on the garden’s dimensions, and the lack of detailed information about the garden’s features (e.g., landscaping, sheds) warrants a middling score.