The list price of £599,950 seems relatively reasonable considering the property’s apparent new build status, size, and location in Baildon. Comparable properties in the area, while limited in data provided, suggest prices ranging from £400,000 to over £600,000. The lack of precise square footage data for nearby properties makes a precise per-square-foot comparison difficult. However, the price appears to be within the expected range for a similar property in the area. The lack of detailed plot size information also affects the overall price assessment, leading to a score of 7.

The property appears to be a new build or very recently constructed, based on the provided photographs. The interior and exterior finishes look modern, well-maintained, and of high quality. There is no visible evidence of disrepair or the need for renovation. This justifies a score of 9.

Baildon is a desirable village in West Yorkshire, known for its good schools and transport links. The proximity to train stations providing access to larger cities like Bradford and Leeds is a plus. The presence of several well-regarded schools within a reasonable distance further enhances its appeal. However, the specific location on Reservoir Way, while seemingly elevated and offering views, might not be as central as some other parts of Baildon, hence a score of 7.

While the property includes a garden, its size is not explicitly stated and the images suggest a relatively small garden area compared to the size of the house. There is also limited information on the overall plot size. A modest garden is present, but it does not stand out as exceptionally large, hence a score of 4.